Blog

The #1 Reason Strategic Plans Fail (and How to Prevent It)

Written by Bo McDonald | Dec 3, 2025 5:46:57 PM

 

 

It is not your strategy. It is your capacity.

The strategic planning season is here. Some credit unions just wrapped up their planning sessions. Others are heading into final reviews for the plan they created months ago. No matter where you are in that cycle, a familiar feeling often creeps in:

Why does this look great on paper, but nothing seems to happen afterward?

The truth is, most strategic plans fail quietly. Not because the goals are unrealistic. Not because the team is unmotivated. The most common reason is much simpler.

Your team is too full.

Strategic Plans Fail When Capacity Is Ignored

There are three parts of capacity every credit union should assess before finalizing its plan:

1. Time

Do you actually have the hours available to execute the work? Day-to-day operations do not disappear simply because new goals exist.

2. Ability

Do the right people have the right skills? New technology or marketing initiatives often require expertise that does not currently exist internally.

3. Fit

Visionary strategies without structure overwhelm operational thinkers. Process heavy plans slow down innovators. When style and responsibilities clash, progress stalls.

Miss any one of these three, and your strategic plan gets stuck in what we call the capacity deficit. It slowly fades while everyone feels frustrated, overloaded, or even defeated.

The Double Hat Problem

Every credit union leader and employee wears two hats:

• Run the credit union
• Transform the credit union

Both matter. Both demand energy. But when both exist without additional support, burnout becomes inevitable.

What happens next?

• Tasks pile up
• Delegation does not happen
• Resentment builds
• The plan becomes a binder on a shelf
• Next year’s planning starts with the words nobody wants to hear:
“We did not accomplish last year’s goals.”

Before You Finalize Your Plan: Do a Capacity Check

This is where change starts. Bring your team together and ask:

• What will this actually take in time and resources?
• What can be delegated or removed entirely?
• Where do we lack skills and structure?
• How can we create clarity in responsibilities?
• How will we reconnect weekly to prevent drift?
• What training do we need to support execution?
• Who will raise their hand early if they feel overwhelmed?

These are not administrative questions. They are strategic ones.

You Do Not Have to Do It Alone

Capacity is more than headcount. Creative staffing is a real advantage:

• Fractional marketing help
• New vendors to support transformation
• Temporary expertise for growth initiatives

Finding time is a legitimate strategy.

The Plans That Win Are the Plans You Can Execute

Credit unions exist to serve members and build stronger communities. A strategic plan that never leaves the room cannot do either.

Ask a better question this year:

Not only “What should we do?”
But also “Do we have the capacity to do it well?”

If the answer is no, that is not a failure. That is leadership.

Let’s Build a Strategic Plan That Works

Your Marketing Co. facilitates strategic planning sessions designed specifically for credit unions. We help you balance vision with capacity so your plan creates real movement.

👉 Want to talk through your current plan? Let’s schedule a discovery call.

Because a plan that fits your team is a plan that transforms your credit union.